Electronic subpoena service

ABSTRACT

A method and system for delivering a subpoena via an electronic subpoena service. The electronic delivery can constitute legal service of the subpoena or be accompanied by hardcopy service. Utilization of a system to serve subpoenas can provide timely and efficient service with an automated audit trail. The system can enable broad service with confirmed identification of relevant parties to be served. An automated search of electronic records provides uniform search criteria an compliance, even with multiple locations and subsidiaries, including foreign subsidiaries. Ongoing searching via real time monitoring of accounts, credit, entities wire transfer and other activities also provides a level of detail and uniformity heretofore unavailable.

BACKGROUND

[0001] This invention relates generally to a method and system for effecting legal service of a subpoena for information held by a financial or non-financial institution. In particular, the present invention relates to a computerized system and method for banks and non-bank financial institutions to accept service of a subpoena, automatically search their records for any information related to the subject of the subpoena, and generate a response in a timely manner, thereby expediting law enforcement efforts.

[0002] A government agency on the trail of money needs to have access to information contained in the records of banks and other financial institutions. Currently, the government is limited because there is no vehicle that allows the government to effect widespread service of a subpoena which relates to a person or entity which it needs to investigate. Fax subpoenas can be utilized, but fax delivery only affects one small aspect of the subpoena process, which is the delivery of a hardcopy. The logistical problems associated with who to fax a document to, whether the intended recipient is available, whether the fax is received, also must be addressed.

[0003] Another shortcoming with the present system is the lack of coordination amongst agencies conducting investigations which results in inconsistent and non-unified lists of suspect names. One agency may very well not know that another agency is already conducting research into a particular name or to what extent another other agency may have collected information regarding a particular name.

[0004] In another aspect, a bank's lawyers and other financial institution personnel typically have few resources available to assist them with the identification of information associated with a particular subpoena. A substantial amount of information needs to be considered in order to properly comply with a subpoena and to evaluate whether particular information should be provided under the terms of the subpoena. Search criteria and matching are largely subjective and can vary from institution to institution depending upon the skill set and degree of commitment. As a result, based largely upon who conducts a search to comply with a subpoena, one institution may conduct a thorough search of their records and provide results that include a search for alternate spelling of names, aliases, associations or other useful information, while another institution may provide a bare minimum of information.

[0005] Financial institutions do not have available a mechanism which can provide automated real time assistance to receive a subpoena and search their electronic records in a thorough and consistent manner for information associated with international entity or subject of a subpoena. In the event of inexact matches to requested information, it is often a difficult and subjective task to manually review records and ascertain which information should be included in a response to the subpoena. Absent a means with which to timely receive a subpoena and process search their records for any information related to the subpoenaed information, a financial institution may delay law enforcement efforts.

[0006] What is needed is a method and system to accept an electronic subpoena and process the subpoena in an automated and expeditious manner. A new method and system should anticipate offering guidance to personnel who process the subpoena and providing search algorithms and methods which allow the personnel to locate as much pertinent information as is feasible. In addition, the system should allow for an electronic of information responsive to the subpoena. with clients and help the personnel identify high risk situations.

SUMMARY

[0007] Accordingly, a method and system is provided for delivering a subpoena via an electronic subpoena service (ESS system). The electronic delivery can constitute legal service of the subpoena or be accompanied by hardcopy service. Utilization of an ESS system to serve subpoenas can provide timely and efficient service with an automated audit trail. The ESS system can enable broad service with confirmed identification of relevant parties to be served. An automated search of electronic records provides uniform search criteria an compliance, even with multiple locations and subsidiaries, including foreign subsidiaries. Ongoing searching via real time monitoring of accounts, credit, entities wire transfer and other activities also provides a level of detail and uniformity heretofore unavailable.

[0008] The invention includes a computer-implemented method for delivering a subpoena over a distributed network by storing information comprising a subpoena on a computerized server and transmitting the information comprising the subpoena from the server to a designated computerized device; and receiving data responsive to a request contained within the subpoena. In addition it can include receiving an acknowledgement from the computerized device that the information comprising the subpoena had been received and storing the data received wherein it can be combined with additional stored the data. Reports descriptive of the subject of the subpoena can also be generated. Additional data relating to the subpoena from a second computerized server can also be transmitted and received. In implementing the present invention, one or more computerized servers can act responsive to instructions received from different government agencies.

[0009] A search algorithm and executable search software can also be transmitted to a designated computerized device. Data received responsive to a subpoena request can be processed to create new informational requests subject to and included in the subpoena, wherein the new information can also be transmitted from the server to a designated computerized device.

[0010] In another aspect the present invention includes a computer-implemented method for processing an electronic subpoena that includes receiving information comprising a subpoena on a computerized device and searching stored computer records for data relating to a request contained within the subpoena. Data related to a request contained within the subpoena can be transmitted to a designated aggregation device, such as an ESS server.

[0011] A search algorithm related to the request contained within the subpoena can also be received electronically, as can an executable search software program. The software can include code and routines for monitoring transactions on in-house computers and gathering data related to the transactions which also relates to the request contained within the subpoena. The gathered data can be transmitted to the designated aggregation device.

[0012] An updated request subject to the subpoena can also be electronically received which can cause additional searching of stored computer records for data relating to the updated request comprising the subpoena and transmitting data relating to the updated request to a designated aggregation device.

[0013] Still another aspect can include delivering a subpoena by storing information comprising a subpoena on a computerized server and delivering a hardcopy of the subpoena to the subpoenaed party with a subpoena identifier associated the hardcopy of the subpoena, wherein the subpoena identifier uniquely identifies the subpoena. Information included in the subpoena and the subpoena identifier can then be transmitted from the server to a designated computerized device. Data responsive to a request contained within the subpoena can be received..

[0014] Similarly, a subpoena can be accepted and processed by receiving a hardcopy of a subpoena including a subpoena identifier and also receiving electronic information comprising a subpoena and a subpoena identifier with a computerized device. The subpoena identifier can be utilized to confirm that a subpoena received electronically corresponds with the hardcopy subpoena.

[0015] Other implementations include a computerized system for delivering a subpoena, the system including a computer server capable of communicating via a communications network and executable software stored on the server and executable on demand. The software operative with the server to cause the system to perform the methods of the present invention.

[0016] Still other embodiments include computer executable program code residing on a computer-readable medium, a computer data signal embodied in a digital data stream, or a method of interacting with a designated computerized device. Various features and embodiments are further described in the following figures, drawings and claims.

DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0017]FIG. 1 illustrates a block diagram which can embody this invention.

[0018]FIG. 2 illustrates a network on computer systems that can embody an electronic subpoena service system.

[0019]FIG. 3 illustrate a flow of exemplary steps that can be practiced by a provider of an ESS service.

[0020]FIG. 4 illustrates a flow of exemplary steps that can be practiced by a an institution accepting service via an ESS system.

[0021]FIG. 5 illustrates an exemplary graphical user interface useful for interacting with an ESS system.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0022] The present invention includes a computerized method and system for delivering a subpoena via an ESS system. The electronic delivery can constitute legal service of the subpoena or be accompanied by hardcopy service. A computerized system stores information including an electronic version of a subpoena in a database or other data storing structure and transmits the information to a subpoenaed party. The party can be associated with a designated computing device to which the information can be transmitted. Data responsive to a request in the subpoena can be received by the computerized system.

[0023] Utilization of an ESS system to serve subpoenas can provide timely and efficient service with an automated audit trail. The ESS system enables broad service with confirmed identification of relevant parties to be served. An automated search of electronic records provides uniform search criteria an compliance, even with multiple locations and subsidiaries, including foreign subsidiaries. Ongoing searching via real time monitoring of accounts, credit, entities wire transfer and other activities also provides a level of detail and uniformity heretofore unavailable. Automated searching can facilitate use of an algorithm which will capture match variations that may be responsive for regulatory reporting.

[0024] Referring now to FIG. 1 a block diagram of one embodiment of the present invention is illustrated. An ESS system 100 receives information relating to one or more subpoenas which are to be served upon entities, such as for example, a financial institution. The information includes an electronic version of the subpoena, or in one embodiment, sufficient information for the ESS system to compose an electronic subpoena. The subpoena can be received from an issuer of the subpoena 101, for example a government agency such as, the Department of Justice (DOJ), US Attorneys, Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), State Prosecutors, District Attorneys, State Police, Treasury, Office of Foreign Access Control (OFAC), Secret Service, Customs, Drug Enforcement Agency (DEA), or other government agency.

[0025] Preferable the subpoena will be storable in a standard format that can be readily accessible to recipients. For example the subpoena may be received or transmitted in Portable Document Format (PDF) or Rich Text Format (RTF).

[0026] The subpoena issuer 101 will input into the ESS system 100 the content of a subpoena and a list of subpoenaed entities which must be served the subpoena. In one embodiment, the ESS system 100 will maintain a database of contact information relating to subpoenaed entities. In another embodiment, the subpoena issuer 101 will supply contact information with each new subpoena. In either case, the ESS system will distribute the electronic subpoena in order to effect service. Typically, subpoenaed entities 104-107 will include financial institutions 104-106, although other types of entities 107 can also receive electronic service of subpoenas.

[0027] An institution that may implement, or make use of the present invention can include an investment bank, a merchant bank, a commercial bank, a security firm, an asset management company, a hedge fund, a mutual fund, a credit rating agency, a security exchange and bourse, an institutional or individual investor, an auditing firm, a law firm, or other institution who may be involved with financial transactions. Similarly, financial transactions can include investment and merchant banking, public or private financing, commodities and securities trading, commercial and consumer lending, asset management, rating of corporations and securities, public and private equity investment, public and private fixed income investment, or other business related transactions.

[0028] Service is accomplished by the subpoenaed entity 104-107 receiving the subpoena through an electronic communication. The electronic communication can include a push technology wherein the subpoena is transmitted to the subpoenaed entity 104-107 independent of any action on the part of the subpoenaed entity 104-107, or through pull technology, wherein the subpoenaed party will make an affirmative action to receive the subpoena, such as by retrieving the subpoena from a server on a distributed network.

[0029] In one embodiment, an affirmative action can be made by the subpoenaed entity 104-107 which will act as a confirmation that the subpoena has been received by the subpoenaed entity 104-107. An affirmative action can include, for example, an electronic message sent by the subpoenaed entity 104-107, or activation of a programmable device, such as a graphical user interface (GUI) button, check box or other device.

[0030] In another embodiment, a subpoena issuer 101 can employ a process server 102 to accomplish physical service of a hardcopy subpoena upon a representative 103 of the subpoenaed entity 104. The hardcopy subpoena can be accompanied by a unique subpoena identifier, such as an alpha-numeric code or document number. The subpoenaed entity 104 can then access the ESS system 100 and accept delivery of an electronic subpoena corresponding with the hardcopy subpoena which has been received. The electronic subpoena can include searching algorithms or other enhancements not available with the hardcopy, while the hardcopy can satisfy those who prefer to have traditional documents on file.

[0031] Enhancements which can be included with an electronic subpoena can include search software and search algorithms. Distribution of search software to subpoenaed entities 104-107 can create uniformity of searching efforts across the subpoenaed entities 104-107. The searching software can include executable code that is run on the computers of a subpoenaed entity 104-107. The software can search for exact matches as well as variations of spellings, aliases, also known as (aka) references, or other type of fuzzy searches. Those schooled in the art will recognize that many well known programmable searching methodologies can be utilized in this capacity.

[0032] Searching algorithms can also be delivered with an electronic subpoena. The algorithm can be utilized in conjunction with distributed search software or in conjunction with in-house search software used by the subpoenaed entity 104-107.

[0033] Information that is discovered as a result of a subpoena can be electronically transmitted to the ESS system 100. If appropriate, the information received can facilitate the refinement of search criteria and/or algorithms. The refined search algorithms can be subsequently delivered to the subpoenaed entities 104-107. In addition, search algorithms can be utilized to continually monitor records and transactions in real time so that subsequent actions or information received can also be submitted to the subpoena issuer 101.

[0034] An ESS system 100 can act also act as a clearinghouse for subpoenas, wherein various government agencies 101, 101 a, 101 b can coordinate with each other and also access an organized list of subpoenas. The organization of subpoenas and information received as a result of the subpoenas can relieve duplication of efforts by separate agencies or organizations 101, 101 a, 101 b and facilitate the sharing of information uncovered as a result of one investigation with another parallel investigation.

[0035] A preferred embodiment will include a hub and spoke type architecture with various government agencies 101, 101 a, 101 b submit subpoenas to be served upon various financial or other institutions 104-107. The ESS system 100 coordinates the service of each subpoena and the receipt of information pursuant to each subpoena. In addition, the ESS system 100 can act to oversee and organize similar, duplicative or complimentary investigations as they are manifest the subpoenas. Of particular Importance may be the ability to coordinate the handling of non-public information so that it is accessible to the proper parties with a need to know, but still maintained with a proper level of confidentiality.

[0036] A log or other stored history can be created to track service of each subpoena and responses as rendered..

[0037] Referring now to FIG. 2, a network diagram illustrating one embodiment of the present invention is shown. An automated ESS system 100 can include a computerized ESS server 210 accessible via a distributed network 201 such as the Internet, or a private network. A Subpoenaed Entity 220-222 or other party interested in ESS risk management, can use a computerized system or designated computerized device 204-208 to receive, input, transmit or view information processed in the ESS server 210. A protocol, such as the transmission control protocol internet protocol (TCP/IP) can be utilized to provide consistency and reliability.

[0038] Each designated computerized device can include a processor, memory and a user input device, such as a keyboard and/or mouse, and a user output device, such as a display screen and/or printer. The designated computerized devices 204-208 can communicate with the ESS server 210 to access data stored at the ESS server 210. The designated computerized device 204-208 may interact with the ESS server 210 as if the ESS server 210 was a single entity in the network 200. However, the ESS server 210 may include multiple processing and database sub-systems, such as cooperative or redundant processing and/or database servers, that can be geographically dispersed throughout the network 201. In some implementations, groups of designated computerized devices 204-208 may communicate with ESS server 210 through a local area network.

[0039] The ESS server 210 includes one or more databases 202 storing data relating to ESS risk management. The ESS server 210 may interact with and/or gather data from a Subpoenaed Entity 220-222, or other entity who is operating a designated computerized device 204-208. Data gathered from an operator may be structured according to subpoenaed information and organized for future retrieval.

[0040] Typically a user will access the ESS server 210 using client software executed at a designated computerized device 204-208. The client software may include a generic hypertext markup language (HTML) browser, such as Netscape Navigator or Microsoft Internet Explorer, (a “WEB browser”). The client software may also be a proprietary browser, and/or other host access software. In some cases, an executable program, such as a Java™ program, may be downloaded from the ESS server 210 to a designated computerized device and executed at the designated computerized device or other computer as part of the ESS system software. Other implementations include proprietary software installed from a computer readable medium, such as a CD ROM. The invention may therefore be implemented in digital electronic circuitry, computer hardware, firmware, software, or in combinations of the above. Apparatus of the invention may be implemented in a computer program product tangibly embodied in a machine-readable storage device for execution by a programmable processor; and method steps of the invention may be performed by a programmable processor executing a program of instructions to perform functions of the invention by operating on input data and generating output.

[0041] Referring now to FIG. 3, electronic service of a subpoena can begin with opening a dialogue with an ESS system 310. Typically, the dialogue would be opened by presenting a GUI to a designated computerized device accessible by a person. The GUI will be capable of accepting data input via a designated computerized device. An example of a GUI would include an image of a subpoena and can also include search criteria or algorithms. A dialogue can include transmission and receipt of information. Information can be received directly into fields of a database or in free form.

[0042] Information can be transmitted and received on an ongoing basis such that if new events or information can further facilitate the gathering of subpoenaed information, an ESS search algorithm can be adjusted accordingly.

[0043] The ESS server can associate a subpoenaed entity 104-107 with a designated computerized device 311. A corresponding subpoena as well as search software and algorithm can be transmitted from the ESS server to the subpoenaed entity via the designated computerized device 312. The ESS server can also receive a confirmation of receipt of the subpoena from the subpoenaed entity 313.

[0044] Informational data can also be received into the ESS server pursuant to the subject of the subpoena 314. The ESS server can organize the subject matter of the subpoena, the subpoenaed entities, subpoenaed information and other data 315, and generate reports or answer queries as appropriate 316. In addition, a search algorithm can be modified according to search results, information received, or other input 316.

[0045] Referring now to FIG. 4, an subpoenaed entity can receive an electronic subpoena as well as search software, search algorithm or other related data 410. a search can be performed on existing data 411 and an ongoing real-time monitor or search can also be implemented to constantly update the results of the subpoena for new transactions and data 412.

[0046] The results of a search responsive to the electronic subpoena can be transmitted to the ESS server 413 and a modified search algorithm and/or search software can be received 414. The process can loop back to continually perform the search of existing data, monitor new data in real-time and receive updated search algorithm until the expiration of a subpoena timeframe. Throughout the process, compliance with the subpoena can be tracked by the ESS server and/or the subpoenaed entity's computer systems 415. As a result either system can also generate reports indicating the extent of compliance 416.

[0047] Referring now to FIG. 5, an exemplary GUI for receiving information related to ESS risk management is illustrated 500. The GUI can include areas prompting for information, such as in the form of a key word or a question 501. Areas can also be included for an appropriate response 506. The area for an appropriate response 506 can, for example, receive text, allow a selection from choices proffered, or otherwise receive data into the computerized ESS system 100. A programmable user interactive device, such as a checkbox, X field, yes/no filed or other device can be utilized to indicate an answer, or otherwise input information 503-505. An image of a subpoena 510 can also be indicated on the GUI. The receiving information GUI 500 can also include areas for displaying information transmitted responsive t a subpoena 511.

[0048] A number of embodiments of the present invention have been described. Nevertheless, it will be understood that various modifications may be made without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention. For example, designated computerized devices 204-208 can comprise a personal computer executing an operating system such as Microsoft Windows™, Unix™, or Apple Mac OS™, as well as software applications, such as a JAVA program or a web browser. designated computerized devices 204-208 can also be a terminal device, a palm-type computer, mobile WEB access device, a TV WEB browser or other device that can adhere to a point-to-point or network communication protocol such as the Internet protocol. Computers and designated computerized devices can include a processor, RAM and/or ROM memory, a display capability, an input device and hard disk or other relatively permanent storage. Accordingly, other embodiments are within the scope of the following claims. 

What is claimed is:
 1. A computer-implemented method for delivering a subpoena over a distributed network, the method comprising: storing information comprising a subpoena on a computerized server; transmitting the information comprising the subpoena from the server to a designated computerized device; and receiving data responsive to a request contained within the subpoena.
 2. The method of claim 1 additionally comprising the step of receiving an acknowledgement from the designated computerized device that the information comprising the subpoena had been received.
 3. The method of claim 2 additionally comprising the steps of: storing the data received; combining the data with additional stored data; and generating a report descriptive of the subject of the subpoena.
 4. The method of claim 3 wherein the additional stored data comprises information received from an additional subpoena.
 5. The method of claim 1 additionally comprising transmitting and receiving additional data relating to the subpoena from a second computerized server.
 6. The method of claim 5 wherein the first computerized server and the second computerized server act responsive to instructions received from different government agencies.
 7. The method of claim 1 additionally comprising the step of transmitting a search algorithm to the computerized device.
 8. The method of claim 7 additionally comprising the step of transmitting executable search software to the computerized device.
 9. The method of claim 7 additionally comprising the step of transmitting variations of subject matter contained in the subpoena to the computerized device.
 10. The method of claim 1 additionally comprising the steps of: processing the data received responsive to a request comprising the subpoena; creating new information comprising the subpoena; and transmitting the new information comprising the subpoena from the server to a designated computerized device.
 11. A computer-implemented method for processing an electronic subpoena, the method comprising: receiving information comprising a subpoena on a computerized device; searching stored computer records for data relating to a request contained within the subpoena; and transmitting data related to a relating to the request contained within the subpoena to a designated aggregation device.
 12. The method of claim 11 additionally comprising receiving a search algorithm related to the request contained within the subpoena.
 13. The method of claim 11 additionally comprising receiving an executable search software program.
 14. The method of claim 11 additionally comprising the steps of: monitoring transactions; gathering data related to the transactions which also relates to the request contained within the subpoena; and transmitting the gathered data to the designated aggregation device.
 15. The method of claim 11 additionally comprising the steps of: receiving an updated request comprising the subpoena; searching stored computer records for data relating to the updated request comprising the subpoena; and transmitting data relating to the updated request comprising the subpoena to a designated aggregation device.
 16. A method for delivering a subpoena, the method comprising: storing information comprising a subpoena on a computerized server; delivering a hardcopy of the subpoena to the subpoenaed party; delivering a subpoena identifier with the hardcopy of the subpoena, wherein the subpoena identifier uniquely identifies the subpoena; transmitting the information comprising the subpoena and the subpoena identifier from the server to a designated computerized device; and receiving data responsive to a request contained within the subpoena.
 17. A method for processing a subpoena, the method comprising: receiving a hardcopy of a subpoena including a subpoena identifier; receiving electronic information comprising a subpoena and a subpoena identifier with a computerized device; confirming the subpoena identifier received electronically corresponds with the hardcopy subpoena identifier; searching stored computer records for data relating to a request contained within the subpoena; and transmitting data related to a relating to the request contained within the subpoena to a designated aggregation device.
 18. A computerized system for delivering a subpoena, the system comprising: a computer server capable of communicating via a communications network; and executable software stored on the server and executable on demand, the software operative with the server to cause the system to: store information comprising a subpoena on a computerized server; transmit the information comprising the subpoena from the server to a designated computerized device; and receive data responsive to a request contained within the subpoena.
 19. The computerized system of claim 18 wherein transmissions reception of data is accomplished via a dedicated electronic communications link.
 20. The computerized system of claim 18 wherein the computerized device is a personal computer.
 21. The computerized system of claim 18 wherein the enterprise computer.
 22. Computer executable program code residing on a computer-readable medium, the program code comprising instructions for causing a computer to: store information comprising a subpoena on a computerized server; transmit the information comprising the subpoena from the server to a designated computerized device; and receive data responsive to a request contained within the subpoena.
 23. A computer data signal embodied in a digital data stream comprising data relating to service of a subpoena, wherein the computer data signal is generated by a method comprising the steps of: storing information comprising a subpoena on a computerized server; transmitting the information comprising the subpoena from the server to a designated computerized device; and receiving data responsive to a request contained within the subpoena.
 24. A method of interacting with a computerized device so as to receive and respond to a subpoena, the method comprising the steps of: initiating interaction with a host computer on a communications network; inputting information via a graphical user interface, wherein the information identifies an entity to which a subpoena is to be served; downloading a subpoena; and acknowledging receipt of the subpoena. 